By Chris Warren.
If you can’t say anything nice…
Artificial intelligence, rightly, gets a bad rap. It’s true: it has displaced people from their jobs, made bad decisions that a human would not have made, created vast violations of privacy, and consumes a lot of energy and resources. It barely existed until recently, and it’s upending our lives. Even with all that, I have to admit artificial intelligence is a net benefit to society. When the good is balanced with the bad, the good wins. But my recent experiences with artificial intelligence have me questioning the “intelligence” part.
You often miss your own mistakes.
I do a lot of writing for another website. It keeps me quite busy; that’s why this website is so seldom updated. The thing is, every writer needs a copy editor. That person should not be the writer themselves. It’s human nature to overlook one’s own errors. Have you ever asked someone to proofread your paper, and they immediately spot a glaring mistake that you missed probably a dozen times? That’s why guys like me need copy editors.
Until the last year or so, I was my own copy editor. As a freelancer, this job does not accommodate hiring a human to do it for me. Against my intuition, I had no choice but to edit my own work. Applications like spell check, SEO analysis, and WordPress readability scoring help a little, but most of the heavy lifting I had to do myself. It wasn’t always easy or elegant, but time after time I managed to produce a presentable, polished product.
Enter the robot.
As a Gen X-er who is old enough to have lived before the internet and young enough to embrace it, the rise of artificial intelligence grabbed my attention. At first, I used it to pull up random facts when I was too lazy to sort through Google results and figure out what was real and what was BS. And yeah, I sheepishly admit I use it, sparingly, to make stupid memes as a prank. You’ve certainly heard all the chatter about how data centers consume huge amounts of electricity and water. Imagine how much less that consumption would be if no one was using AI to create dancing cat videos. Doh!
Then the light bulb went on in my head. Use artificial intelligence as my copy editor! I’m certain I’m not the first guy to think of this, but for a moment it made me feel like a visionary.
Now, to be clear, everything I publish is my own original composition. But I did adopt AI to check spelling, sentence structure and grammar, logic flow, and fact verification. Most of my writing involves technical and engineering topics. In mere seconds, artificial intelligence can dig up obscure data that would take me weeks or even months to find. These are all legitimate uses of AI. It frees me to write about topics that I otherwise would not touch, or at least not address with as much depth.
Artificial intelligence can go through my text with more speed and accuracy than any human. I don’t always agree with issues it flags. I reserve my human veto power, and I often reject AI’s suggestions. But on the whole, it catches a lot of boo-boos. In some cases it declares a passage properly written but recommends a better way of stating it. I’m more reserved about approving those types of editorial changes because I don’t want AI writing “my” articles. Fidelity means everything to me. It’s a very big deal that my work actually be my work.
True colors.
Artificial intelligence creates and perpetuates a lot of boo-boos too. The deeper I got into using AI for editorial purposes, the more the gremlins came out. It would suggest a change. I would make the change. Then later in the process it would suggest I change it back. When I called out the robot on the contradiction, it would say something along the lines of, “Well, you were right the first time.” Whaaaat? The longer I worked on a project, the less detailed responses became.
I thought maybe the robot was not trying too hard because I was using the free version. This manifested itself mostly when I tried creating graphs and tables. It would give me the initial image, but if I attempted too many edits, it would halt and tell me to either upgrade or wait some period of time. Just as people only work as hard as you pay them to, I suspect it’s the same with robots. As a devoted free-market capitalist who wholeheartedly buys into the concept of exchanging money for goods and services, I forked over some money and upgraded. I use AI enough to warrant the modest monthly charge.

At your service?
Not at all to my surprise, after paying my bounty to the overlord the responses became consistently detailed from beginning to end. And if there is a limit as to how many graphic/image edits I can make, I haven’t hit it yet. Money talks, and robots listen.
My frustration boiled over when I needed artificial intelligence to create a technical diagram for an article I was writing. Overall the initial image was pretty good, but had small errors that needed fixing. It would fix one error and then create another. The chatbot would reverse a correction after being told not to touch it. This was a very simple circuit. I wasn’t asking for anything weird. I even uploaded an accurate technical schematic as an example it could work from, and it fed me back garbage. It wasn’t even close! What am I doing wrong? Did I not give it enough money? I went in circles with the machine for eight hours before I finally gave up.
In passing I mentioned this drama to my brother, who has been tinkering with AI a lot longer than me. He asked if he could take a shot at it. OK, fine. Why not. I sent the hopelessly botched-up image over. To my slight embarrassment, he sent back a perfect A+ publication-ready graphic exactly as I specified. Admittedly, it took him a while. This was no five-minute wizard fix. But he did pull it off. All he said was, “You need to know how to talk to it.” I wasn’t aware I needed to speak fluent “robot English.” Gee thanks, bro?
Intelligence gathering.
So what is my takeaway from this? I think after fighting it for a full workday, I’ve proven that I don’t give up too quickly. My brother bailed me out this time, but asking him to whisper his magic whenever I need an image made is not a real option. Maybe I just need more practice and experience. That would be a painful process, but worth it if I ultimately gain the skills. In case you didn’t already suspect, yes, I absolutely did use AI to edit and proofread this article, and it took minutes not hours.
Artificial intelligence is still in its nascent stages. If it were a car, it would be a crank-start, 1920s-era Model T. Yeah, artificial intelligence is impressive and cool for what it is, but it’s going to be a while before we don’t have to crank it anymore. Until then, I’ll just have to wear my arm out getting it to obey.








